Claims boundary · read before citing
These seven boundaries are a result, not a footnote. Most importantly: we have not shown that music causally improves cognitive working capability.
- ✕ 01
We have not established that music causally improves cognitive working capability.
MindWave has no music conditions. In PhysioNet every participant heard the conditions in the same order; the 36.5% → 51.8% gain is a learning curve, the music-condition RM-ANOVA is non-significant (p = 0.207) and no EEG band differs across conditions after FDR (all q ≥ 0.90).
- ✕ 02
We have not established that EEG-guided music selection reduces perceived mental fatigue.
Neither dataset recorded NASA-TLX, the Karolinska Sleepiness Scale or any subjective fatigue scale across blocks.
- ✕ 03
We have not established that our models generalize to unseen users.
Generic models on unseen participants scored 50.0%–51.2%. The validated models are personalized and need calibration data from each user.
- ✕ 04
We have not established that 4-channel Muse findings transfer to single-channel MindWave hardware.
PhysioNet’s strongest effects were temporoparietal (TP10, d_z = 1.26); MindWave records only FP1, in unscaled counts, without mastoid references.
- ✕ 05
We have not established that offline classifications translate to real-time, closed-loop operation.
All evaluations used pre-recorded, zero-phase filtered epochs. Streaming needs causal filtering and faces buffer latency, motion and impedance drift.
- ✕ 06
We have not established an optimal calibration duration.
The 20% budget (12.4 min, 55.64%) and the 50% budget (57.06% on the common set) describe an observed trend on retrospective data, not a proven optimum.
- ✕ 07
We have not established that heuristic artifact screening removes all physiological contaminants.
Neither dataset has EOG/EMG channels; blinks, saccades and frontalis/temporalis tone can survive amplitude thresholds such as 200 µV.